|
|
||||
![]() |
![]() |
|||
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
||
![]() |
||||
![]() |
||||
|
|
September 12-18, 2002 political notebook JudiciousOne thing gubernatorial candidates Ed Rendell and Mike Fisher agree on is that they disagree on the way we elect judges in this state. Rendell and Fisher, who are both lawyers, were scheduled to get together here in Philadelphia at the PBI-PBEC Education Center last Wednesday to talk about this issue, but Rendell had a scheduling conflict and gave his remarks by video. Fisher attended the forum, hosted by the Pennsylvanians for Modern Courts (PMC), a nonprofit statewide organization that focuses on the quality of the judicial system, including the jury process and eliminating bias in the courts. PMC favors merit selection of appellate court judges versus the partisan election process that is in place now. Both Rendell and Fisher also support merit selection. PMC does not recommend that the governor appoint all his cronies to the bench; they support a diversified bipartisan nominating commission that would submit a list of qualified candidates to the governor. The governor would then nominate a candidate from that list. Now that the state Supreme Court ruling has allowed judicial candidates to be able to speak freely while campaigning, that also opens up a whole new can of worms. Currently, all judicial candidates, both in the appellate and lower courts, must campaign and raise money like any other candidate. The average person couldn't care less about judicial elections. So who does? Lawyers. Lawyers attend judicial fundraisers, the same lawyers who may appear later before that candidate, once appointed. The PMC forum, hosted by Chair Clifford Haines, and Executive Director Lynn Marks, was a venue for discussion on the issue and was attended primarily by lawyers but some judges as well. "We are only one of six states that still elect all of our judges in partisan elections," said Marks. Rendell, in his video appearance, said he has been pushing for merit selection since he was the district attorney in 1978. "The way we elect judges makes no sense at all," said Rendell. "There is an incredible cost for what it takes to run a statewide campaign -- well over a million dollars. And that creates incredible pressure on the candidate, although a judicial candidate cannot raise money directly. The only contributors are lawyers or special interest groups, people who pretty much know they will be in front of a judge," said Rendell. "Judges are supposed to be neutral, they are supposed to listen to the arguments and read the briefs," said Rendell, whose wife, Midge Rendell, is a federal judge. Another reason Rendell said he was for merit selection was that usually only candidates from the southwestern part of the state, or Philadelphia, get elected. "If you were a brilliant trial lawyer from Northumberland County, you have no chance," he said. He concluded by saying that merit selection is not taking away the people's right to choose because of the broad-based selection panel that would be in place for nominations. Fisher concurred. "I have been working in the trenches to get merit selection done for the last 15 years," Fisher said in his opening remarks. Fisher mentioned that he does not always fully agree with the way the Pennsylvania Bar Association has gone about selecting and rating candidates. "But the fact that they have a process is an improvement," he said. Judicial candidates usually fear the bar associations in their respective counties because a non-recommended rating from an association is an embarrassment. However, in lower court elections in Philadelphia, most candidates are picked by their party, get party support and do not need a recommendation from the bar to get elected to the bench. "The Republican party has shown that they support qualified candidates," said Fisher, referring to the last election when the GOP took the state in the appellate courts. "But the system we have today still is not the best," he added. Fisher suggested that the nominating panel have legislation representation because, he explained, "if this panel sends a name just to the Senate, it will be doomed for failure." Despite the fact that merit selection is focused on the appellate courts, Fisher wants it to reach the lower courts, particularly here in the city. Last year Fisher, who is the state attorney general, led a grand jury investigation from the Bureau of Criminal Investigations in his office, centered around financial transactions during the 1997 and 1999 Municipal and Common Pleas Court elections. Four ward leaders were charged with misdemeanors for failing to file campaign expense reports and the illegal disbursement and receipt of election money. "Everyone should be ashamed of the way we elect judges here in Philadelphia," said Fisher. PhasionistasDesigner Nicole Miller is this year’s honoree at the ninth annual Phashion Phest, to be held at the Festival Pier at Penn’s Landing on Sept. 18. Phashion Phest is hosted by Deputy City Representative Bonnie Grant and produced by local fashionista Sharon Phillips Waxman.Phashion Phest promotes the city as a fashion destination by showcasing the local retail industry with a cocktail party and fashion show. Call 267-321-7724 or visit www.phashionphest.com for more information.
-- Respond to this article in our Forums -- click to jump there
Recent Comments
Dave Marris `Wow Pat - -
Aren't you a prime example of an ugly American?` » Dave Marris `Hi Jan!
Happy Independence day to you too!
I'm curious... what exactly do you think we are celebrating our independence from?
I'm also wondering ` » Dave Marris `I am Jan Mohammad AZAD
the Administrative Manager, EODT-ANTC, Herat Province, Afghanistan. Mr. Dave is officially my Supervisor and personally my best ` » By the Sword `Eileen wasnt a real mother . her son anthony was raised by darlene , diane , and roe . they mad him the man he was . and everybody's day comes . the story ` » By the Sword `sleep in heaven anthony ! its so crazy . i could picture it like it was yesterday . when i seen that room . i seen you in the sky . i couldnt belive it ` » Soldiering On `yeah i'd really like to see CP feature a Cieri article detailing the evidence connecting 911 and Iraq or better yet North Korea !
This fluff propaganda ` » Where'd I order these cocktails? `Will:
You got it. My girlfriend got the thingie on the left (can't remember its name) and I got the Old Fashioned on the right.` » Where'd I order these cocktails? `Chick's` » Kilimandjaro Restaurant `Greg,I agree with you.I also visited Soleil de Minuit last year when City paper review them the food was excellent, they also have good food 62nd and ` » Kilimandjaro Restaurant
`I visited that place 2 times the food was'nt good compare to other african Restaurant like Malian Soleil De Minuit ,I think they all from west Africa ` »
Popular Articles
What Does It Take to Make the NBA? And does Dionte Christmas have it? Coop d'état A South Philly street has gone to the birds. The 10 Best Cheesesteaks You've Never Had Let our expert expand your grease-stained horizons. In the Wurst Way German food is poised to make a major local comeback thanks to Brauhaus Schmitz. Biketopia
How to make Philly a cyclist's paradise. Search Restaurants
Search Movies
Search Events
Search DJ Nights
Search Classifieds
Search Real Estate
ADVERTISEMENT
It's hard to know what to get a dead president for his birthday, but surely Abe would approve of Lincoln's ... more »» | |||||||||||||||||||||||||