CONCERT REVIEW: Philadelphia Folk Festival

The Web site for the award-winning alternative weekly, the Philadelphia City Paper.

email
font size
comments
0
share
options
 

CONCERT REVIEW: Philadelphia Folk Festival

POSTED: Thursday, August 26, 2010, 10:04 PM
John Vettese
Hoots and Hellmouth
The Philadelphia Folk Fest is almost always about moments. The three-day musical endurance test — four days for those in the campground — typically comes with stuffy heat, slippery rain, or both. By the end of it, full performances aren't the things that stand out – they can be a blur. Often it takes a moment within the performance to really transcend, to really make the festival. This year, there were moments aplenty.
    MOMENT 1: Thursday evening, Hoots and Hellmouth loses power, soldiers on
The feisty Philly revival tent trio had already worked their way through a smokin' Camp Stage set when, just as the sing-song coda of "Home in a Boxcar" kicked in, the power kicked out. Like perfectly timed. The chord changes led into the freight-train whistle harmonized "Whoo-woo," and suddenly everything was gone — lights, sound, etc. The guys (and their four backing musicians, including ubiquitous harmonica player Bob Beach) walked to the front of the stage, urging the audience to clap along, to sing along. They obliged. This continued for quite some time. My initial thought was it was a gimmick, a trick pre-planned and co-consipred with the house crew. But it just kept going — two minutes, three minutes, no power return. But the revelers kept clapping, kept "whoo-who"-ing in the night air bliss. Finally, as abruptly as it died, lights and sound returned, the band picked up their instruments, and picked up where they left off, to everyone's collective delight. I was still skeptical — was this some showmanship ruse? Festival programmer Jesse Lundy and Hoots mandolinist / banjoist Rob Berliner both told me it totally was not. "That was cosmic," Berliner said. "You don't plan something like that." The cynic in me thinks, well, if it was an illusion, of course promoter and performer would have you believe it was real. The spectator in me thinks that everybody singing along, clapping along, and not letting go for such a huge duration was pure magic.
John Vettese
    MOMENT 2: Friday afternoon, The Spinning Leaves jerk tears
OK, I'll admit it. "Bridges For Free" broke my would-be hard façade. Coming out of 12 people, horns and strings and voices resonating beautifully from the festival mainstage, that "Love landed in Philadelphia" line and hundreds of people cheering behind me — yeah, I got misty-eyed. Looks from the photo above that versatile guitarist Andy Keenan did too, and Leaves singer Barbara Gettes told me afterward that she had a hard time holding her composure amid it all. To some, she and Michael Baker might come off as flighty idealists when they talk about the power of people and what we can all do together, but there it is, there's your proof. They're not kidding.
John Vettese
    MOMENT 3: Friday evening, Bonnie "Prince" Billy, aloof and awkward, singlehandedly puts 1,500 people to sleep
Since none of the reaction I've heard to Will Oldham's much-anticipated set was positive, I'll say this much: His band was pointed and precise, and their nuanced interpretation of the delicate woodshedding-on-the-Great-Plains harmonies from The Wonder Show of the World (the latest Bonnie "Prince" Billy release) was pleasing. For about the first 45 minutes. The music, while graceful, is mellow. So, so very mellow. Practically sub-audible. And it continued for close to an hour and a half. Oldham/Billie did not appear comfortable being on such a big stage (unless awkward discomfort is part of his constructed Bonnie "Prince" persona), so he'd retreat to the drum riser, or struggle awkwardly with a melodica, or give the Old Pool Farm an unrelenting thousand yard stare. One by one, spectators began nodding off to the Cairo Gang's frustratingly quiet strains. This would have been a much better afternoon concert, when patience was more plentiful — at night, it felt interminable. Part of the frustration certainly had to do with the Bonnie "Prince" Billy mystique: Lots of people were looking forward to this set, but nobody really knew what to expect, as Oldham has built a career out of circumventing expectations. And while I wasn't chomping at the bit to see perennial festival hacks Gandalf Murphy and the Slambovian Circus of Dreams follow him by robo-playing the same five songs they do every year, I wasn't wanting Oldham's Gambit to continue much longer. In the end, the highlights were seeing Meg Baird grace the Folk Fest stage once again, and realizing that the set was over so I could make my way to my tent.
John Vettese
    MOMENT 4: Saturday afternoon, Adam Brodsky is pleasantly surprised that people remember the lyrics to "Cubicle Girl"
Seriously. I forgot all about this dude and that song, but he was everywhere in the early aughts. Literally. Fifty states in 50 days and all that. But at a Tank Stage musical comedy workshop, Brodsky got a cheery singalong going to his signature tune ("I see 'em all the time at 18th and JFK / O lord send a cubicle girl my way") that took him unawares — and made fellow panelist (and former labelmate) Butch Ross crack up. Ross didn't do his song about the Trenton Makes bridge, though. Bummed about that.
John Vettese
    MEANWHILE, BACK AT CAMP...: The Topless Foot Race delivers what it promises
Folk Fest's campground is one part Monty Python school of absurdist theater, one part bacchanalian frat party. To wit: This year's annual topless foot race, a bare-chested sprint up the campground's steep main drag, featured three women participants. That's three more than signed up last year, I'm told. Apparently this thing is usually a shitshow of moobs.
John Vettese
    MOMENT 5: Saturday afternoon, Jeff Tweedy tells a rock tale
Of course somebody yelled "rock n' roll" at Mr. Wilco, and of course he made the requisite comment about "Isn't this a folk show?" Then he told us "a rock 'n roll story." In his candid, casual manner that can make the most inane stuff compelling, Tweedy the solo acoustic troubadour described an ill-fated pizza dinner with family the night before. He held up his infant nephew and got pizza-puke all over his face. He washed up and went to bed. The next morning, he discovered a piece of pepperoni crusted in his beard. "I slept all night with a puked-up piece of pepperoni on my face," he said. "That's pretty rock n' roll." Someone asked what became of the peperoni. "Oh, I ate it." Awesome.
John Vettese
    MOMENT 6: Saturday night, Taj Mahal emotes
I could point to the variety in legendary guitarist Taj Mahal's set — how it moved from rough and ribald blues to the chiming West African guitar styles of his 1999 album with Toumani Diabate, Kulanjan. I could talk about how tight the time tested three-piece was, or how they too played for 90 minutes and yet left me wanting more. The thing that stands out most about Taj's performance was how he emoted. His facial expressions. Every note triggered a corresponding eyebrow arch, a pop of the eyes, a knowing head shake or shrugging suave sway, a puckered-up kiss face made to the microphone. Punctuating his music this way, Taj not only gave us something lively to look at – he became a full-body vessel for his songs, something where the music and the character began to seem inseparable.
John Vettese
    MEANWHILE, BACK AT CAMP...: Aliens invade! Robots attack!
Oh, don't worry. This happens every year.
John Vettese
    MOMENT 7: Sunday morning, rain brings the Lee Harvey Osmond crowd onstage
Their churning acid folk and lively wit was a great Sunday morning wake-up on the Camp Stage. But Canadian four-piece Lee Harvey Osmond won the most points when the skies opened up for the third time that day; noting the crowd retreating back to their tents, singer / guitarist Tom Wilson invited folks to stay and gather under the awning protecting him and his gear. A handful of eager listeners took him up on the offer, piling to the stage and sitting cross-legged, like it was story time at the Schewnksville library.
John Vettese
    MOMENT 8: Saturday afternoon, Cheers Elephant frightens Folk Fest octogenarians
Now I'm not quite sure what exactly the boisterous Philly indie-psych four piece Cheers Elephant was doing on this lineup. The closest they came to "folk" was an electric bluegrass'd reimagining of their song "Mr. Marvelous." But mostly they did what they do so well — amp-peakin', high-kickin', loud guitar jams. Halfway into their set, an elderly attendee walked in, stood right in front of the largely seated crowd and stared scoldingly at the band. His fingers plugged his ears, his eyes pleaded that these kids and their rock n' roll would hush up. But the band played on. Their new song "Como Es La Vida" was epic. And the Lobby Tent crowd screamed. Did Cheers Elephant fit at Folk Fest? Of course not. Were they any good? Absolutely. Did they make an impact? Oh hell yes.
John Vettese
    MEANWHILE, BACK AT CAMP...: An epic water balloon battle rages on
Shoulda got combat pay for this one!
John Vettese
    MOMENT 9: Sunday evening, Iain Matthews and Richard Thompson stage a mini-Fairport reunion
Good on Philebrity for predicting that the two former Fairport Conventioneers would engage in musical camaraderie while sharing a lineup on the closing day of Folk Fest. During Matthews' stately, classy evening set, Thompson emerged from backstage to collaborate on Joni Mitchell's "Woodstock," plucking improve leads and strumming with intensity while his onetime bandmate wailed out the high notes. During Thompson's closing set later that night, Matthews came out for the encore, the two collaborating on Fairport numbers this time, a fine treat for the soggy few who stuck the day out.
jesselun
Posted 2010-08-27 10:08:16
John, best review of the event, as usual. I'm surprised to hear you saying Bonnie "Prince" Billy was boring, etc, especially from the #1 proponent of having Espers on the Martin Stage. Also, not sure if your watch stopped, but his set was 50 mins. Was it too much? Only for the people who didn't get it. As we both know, Will Oldham is probably more versed in traditional folk music than most of the other main stage performers, whether he chose to do it there or not...gotta keep pushing this thing forward, know what I mean?

Also, Cheers Elephant are part of the Folk Song Society's Coop program. Gotta have one blast of rock & roll every year in the Tent, right?

Love you
Andy Braunfeld
Posted 2010-08-27 11:40:30
John, there no cosmic showmanship in the power failure. The stage was on generator power, and a faulty sensor in the fuel gauge shut the generator down because it thought it was out of fuel. The entire unit was replaced on Saturday. Wish we had thought of it though...
Andy Braunfeld
Festival Director
One of Four
Posted 2010-08-27 12:45:51
John,

For the record--there were four of us topless female brave souls, not three. As a first-time festival-goer, I really thought it would be more! Next year, gentleman, if you want to cheer us on again, I suggest you talk more of your girlfriends, wives, sisters, and mamas into joining the fun. A critical mass would make it so much more pleasant for all. (And I never did quite get the point of the topless men running, anyway)

--One of Four
Levi Landis
Posted 2010-08-27 13:16:13
Great review.  I tend to agree that my Festival experiences are recalled and cherished in moments.  Cheers and thanks...

Levi Landis
Executive Director
Philadelphia Folksong Society
Lisa Schwartz
Posted 2010-08-27 14:13:29
John, over the years you have been a wonderfully loyal supporter of our event and you don't disappoint with this review.  You've done an excellent job capturing the incredible mosaic that is the Philadelphia Folk Festival; a glorious combination of music, art, and the passion of the performer and attendee alike.  It really is all of the little gems that sparkle throughout the weekend.  Thank you for being a part of it all!

Lisa Schwartz
President, Philadelphia Folksong Society
Chairman, Marketing and Promotions, Philadelphia Folk Festival
George Ehrgott
Posted 2010-08-27 14:15:24
Great review and spot on in all points. There are many more Fest memories we will carry year to year and as a volunteer, we share them forever. As far as Bonnie "Prince" Billy, he is not Bonnie in any way but as Mr Sandman.
Eliot coleman
Posted 2010-08-27 17:50:12
You probably fell asleep to Bonnie because your a turd, and a hack writer. Go folk yourself retard. Your jealousy of will oldham is obnoxiously evident. He was the best there, and just cause he didn't play what a bunch of rich yuppie geezers wanted to hear, you demonize him. Check yourself before you wreck yourself , ice cube nigga
Melanie
Posted 2010-08-28 17:43:01
A wonderful collection of moments!  I'm happy I caught so many of these.  It's hard to plan ahead to be where the moments happen.

Here is my collection of moments: http://www.flickr.com/photos/goob712/sets/72157624806031426/detail/
jlee
Posted 2010-08-28 18:00:08
Totally right about the music - underwhelming.  But fest is fest, and it was a good time as always.  I hope they step the musics up with a vengeance for the 50th Anniversary next year.
Melanie
Posted 2010-08-28 18:00:26
By the way, I heard an announcement around the Bonfire that the folks who host the Topless Race will be raising donations next year for breast cancer charities.  Another reason to bring out the girls!
Kevin k
Posted 2010-08-29 17:24:54
Jesse lundy needs to stop the snore bands for the night concerts. Iron & wine put me' to sleep 2 years ago. U need to amp people up for their drive home or walk to the canceling. Seiously dude get a clue.
Kevin k
Posted 2010-08-29 17:25:55
I meant walk to the campground. Oopsy
Chase
Posted 2010-08-30 13:41:36
To Levi Landis:
I would like to extend to you a very sincere FUCK YOU VERY MUCH. Though I enjoyed bonnie "prince" billy's set I did not however appreciate the fact that after a five song set, you found it impossible to let Gandalf Murphy come on for one encore song. And your arrogance continued when Tinkerbelle Lloyd came out to address the angry fans who were expecting more music and you did not even have the decency to turn her microphone back on. I payed $62 to see Gandelf Murphy and for what? For a arrogant asshole like you to not allow them an additional 5 minutes. They were the headlining act and they played the shortest set of the entire night. I love folk music but what I cannot stand is the way you seem to fuck it up every fucking year. Just as last year when the Saturday evening audience was eagerly waiting for Iron & Wine's performance, you allow some shit Rapper and DJ to take the stage for 45 minutes. Everyone who purchased tickets on this years firday night concert deserve refunds and you personally deserve to be smacked. You ruin folk music.
jesselun
Posted 2010-08-30 17:07:24
Kevin, you seemed so sweet when I put you in your jammies and carried you to bed. Or was that when we "walked to the canceling"?
jesselun
Posted 2010-08-30 17:10:59
Hey Chase

Not sure why you think Levi is responsible for this, or why you can't spell the name of your favorite band correctly, or why you paid $62 to see one band, but Gandalf played their contracted time...and kicked ass. 

Perhaps you'll be more inclined to spend 1/3 of that and see them at the 23 East on Nov 5.
megs
Posted 2010-08-31 11:28:44
Dear Chase, 
You are a f'ing idiot. glad you were the only one in the crowd that enjoyed the Bonnie and the Cairo Gang set. I too would've enjoyed Gandalf to play longer but unfortunately, thats what happens at a festival. Bands do not play full, 2 hour sets. I would've enjoyed to see many of the bands play longer, but alas I too was at a festival, not a Galdalf Murphy concert.  Unfortunately for you, your ears are stuffed will arrogance and your mouth is full of hatred.  How bout next time you stay at home and think about how levi landis was wrestlin wolves while you were still suckin on your mother tit.
Seth
Posted 2010-09-09 17:14:00
Well, this was a great review. Definitely agree that Bonnie "Prince" Billy is a bit strange for the Fest and reminded me very much of Espers from two years ago when he put everyone to sleep. Tweedy and Thompson blew my mind this year! Great stuff. In general the line-ups have been getting better every year, so keep up the good work Point Ent! Def gotta keep moving forward and finding new audiences. Oh and that epic water balloon fight? Yeah, that's us... Repeat Offenders vs. Biscuits and Gravy... three years running.
James "Who"
Posted 2010-12-13 17:00:42
Great review! My wife is a huge fan of the Philly Folk Fest--been going 20 years! Next year is the 50th! Whoo hoo!

We like that you all posted about the Philly Folk Fest this summer. I, too, loved Taj Mahal's performance, among others.

I finished a mini-documentary about Folk Fest. Hope you'll watch, like, and share.

http://vimeo.com/17353174

I'd love to know your thoughts.

Thanks! Happy Fest!

James "Who"
Aly
Posted 2010-12-27 03:12:28
I found Bonnie "Prince" Billy and the Cairo Gang's set to be absolutely captivating and one of the more memorable of my folk fest "moments".  Their sound was unique to the environment, yet felt more of an organic sense of belonging than any of the other acts.  They do not have a common sound, hence why common people do not vibe with them.  I found their performance to be transcendent.
Posted by john vettese @ 10:04 PM  Permalink | Post a comment
Comments  (0)


About this blog
Featuring everything from event roundups to concert reviews and sex talk, City Paper's Critical Mass is a space for off-the-wall coverage of Philly's A&E scene.

Follow Critical Mass editors Patrick Rapa and Emily Guendelsberger on Twitter:

@mission2denmark | @emilygee

Blog archives:
Past Archives: