Top Chef D.C. Episode 3: Not picnic baskets - picnic caskets

The Web site for the award-winning alternative weekly, the Philadelphia City Paper.

0 comments

Top Chef D.C. Episode 3: Not picnic baskets — picnic caskets

POSTED: Thursday, July 1, 2010, 10:11 PM
Filed Under: Food TV | Top Chef
This season of Top Chef is shaping up to be pretty awesome, don't you agree?
"Please do your best. It was just yesterday that Johnny asphyxiated a line cook with his chain wallet for making a watery panna cotta."
Quickfire: The transcendently beautiful Padma, joined by the lovely Gail Simmons and clearly-way-into-Rocket from the Crypt Jean Georges pastry chef Johnny Iuzzini (the latter two will host the upcoming Top Chef Just Desserts), challenge the cheftestants to make a pie. AMERICA! Everyone is extremely pissed. Meanwhile, deep in the wilderness of the Pacific Northwest, a wry, telling smile spreads across the lineless face of Special Agent Dale Cooper. "I have no idea where this pie-based Quickfire challenge will lead us," says Cooper, a mug of hot coffee, black as midnight on a moonless night, half-raised to his lips. "But I have a definite feeling it will be a place both wonderful and strange."
OMGZ Agent Dale Cooper and Gail would make such a cute couple! Whaddya say, Gail?
OK that's just rude Gail! Jersey Kev says America like "Amurrica" so I like him. And Arnold whips out the big guns RIGHT AWAY. “I think pies live in the clouds with the unicorns!" he exclaims. "They just appear magically sometimes!” That shit is so Arnold Face-worthy that we're gonna have to roll out ...
ARNOLD FACE IN DRAG ON Y'ALL FOOLS!!!
Alex's pie is criticized for its quiche-ness, Tracey's crust turns out poorly and Ed's purportedly grandma-inspired banana cream pie, tricked out with salted peanut and celery espuma (!), is roundly ridiculed by Gail. "How does it compare to your grandmother's celery espuma?" she asks all Gail-like. Ed is like owwww. (Judges are mean on this episode!) Amanda gets clapped up by Iuzzuni when she leads into her pie description with some "I'm not a pastry chef"-type sentiment. "My grandma is not a pastry chef either, and she can make a pie," Iuzzuni snorts. OK it's settled, Ed's grandma and Johnny's grandma shall box to the death, Broughton's rules!
Picture both as grandmas, one with a sweet pompadour
Kelly and Stephen are praised for their tasty offerings, but Kenny Blalicchio ends up taking the Quickfire, and immunity, for a bad-ass-sounding bananas foster-inspired pie with Chinese five spice. Blalicchio is a threat! Elimination: The chefs are told they must tackle yet another American tradition — the summer picnic — by preparing dishes for 150 Capitol Hill interns at Mt. Vernon, George Washington's idyllic estate. Before we go any further I would like to bring your attention to a viewer poll question Bravo currently has posted on its website:
I get it, because of the INTERNS. You guys just HAD to go for the cheap, infinitely dated Monica Lewinsky reference, didn't you? While we're at it, here's an exclusive sneak peek at next week's viewer poll:
Each chef is required to come up with a main and a side for the Elimination, so they all go frantic-shopping at Whole Foods. This is precisely when Bravo decides to splice in a testimonial from Amanda discussing how she had a lot of drug problems in the early part of her mid-20s. I'm very happy that Amanda says she has kicked those habits, but it's really bizarre how the producers did it — they cut it in super-fast and random and apropos of nothing, like:
Again, very happy that this is no longer the case with Amanda. And despite the fact that Angelo talks a bunch of smack on her in a weird Inigo Montoya-style cadence ("She's actually very smart, but can Amanda beat me? No, she cannot beat me."), she rocks out the Elimination, impressing the judges (including guest Jonathan Waxman) with her ribs and asparagus. (Even Angelo shows love.) Those two end up in the top four, along with Ed, who erases any memory of Celeryespumagate with a spiced tuna loin dish; and Arnold, who rocks flavorful lamb meatballs so good that they end up winning the challenge. Arn's excited that he takes it — a testament to straight skills, I suppose, especially considering he had to peek at Blalicchio's grill setup pre-cooking to get a fix on what to do. "I'm not a grill guy," he states at the outset. "It'll clog the pores way too fast!"
ARNOLD FACE, ART EDITION!
They can't all be winners, of course. At the bottom of the Elimination — Tim, whose pork two ways is overshadowed by Amanda's ribs; the highly-ranked-in-the-Quickfire Stephen, with an "unappealing" bacon-wrapped Chilean sea bass; Jersey Kev, whose Puerto Rican-inspired flank steak and beans/rice is called too safe; and Tracey, who was gonna do Italian sausage but got stuck for time and ended up turning the same meat into slider patties. Like I mentioned before, the judges are cold as ice on this episode (or is it this season?) — after beating up all of the bottom four, Tom C. and Waxman focus the brunt of their ire on Tracey. "My 10-year-old son probably could've made that patty," says Waxman. "If that's what you call Italian food, it's insulting to Italians, me being one," goes Tom C. Owwwwww. Needless to say, Tracey ends up packing her knives and going. Rough!

nick
Posted 2010-07-01 17:23:05
haha holy shit, that picturestrip of amanda is gold jerry, gold!

danya
Posted 2010-07-01 17:28:26
Heard a report from the field that Padma is truly as beautiful in person as she is on TV. Friend was tempted to say, "Wow, I always thought they photoshopped you!" but actually ended up saying, "Wow!" out loud. Just so you know.

Kudos on the exclusive peek at next week's poll. It should do a lot for Bravo's website ranking.

Tweets that mention Top Chef D.C. Episode 3: Not picnic baskets â?” picnic caskets :: Meal Ticket :: Food Blog :: Philadelphia City Paper -- Topsy.com
Posted 2010-07-01 17:44:00
[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Eddie Gehman Kohan. Eddie Gehman Kohan said: RT @mealticket Top Chef D.C. Episode 3 recap — read, comment! http://bit.ly/bB52pt #topchef #topchefdc [...] 

Kendall
Posted 2010-07-01 18:31:27
And the "Headline of the Year" award goes to...

kibby
Posted 2010-07-02 09:16:44
Hahah, this post referenced so many things that I love- Snoop, Twin Peaks and Rocket from the Crypt. Amazing! 
I love how sassy Gail is this season. I hope she keeps it up and just gets sassier.
Finally, Arnold Face in drag. OMG.

Marie DiFeliciantonio
Posted 2010-07-02 09:58:10
Oh, Arnie. Work it, girl.

Molly Eichel
Posted 2010-07-02 11:07:42
I'm sad about Tracey. She talked a big game but it was all for naught. Plus, shut up Gail, you'd be lucky to have Special Agent Dale Cooper.

poncho
Posted 2010-07-02 13:44:47
Omg these recaps are getting funnier and funnier.  Arnold Face in drag is quite possible the best thing ever!

j leo
Posted 2010-07-06 20:36:59
AR-NOLD! AR-NOLD! AR-NOLD! Team Arnold forever.

Twin Peaks and Requiem for a Dream in one post? You've outdone yourself.

I'm always amused by the sheer terror that comes anytime desserts are invoolved. You'd think by now the chefs would know that if they sign up for this show, eventually they'd need to make a dessert at some point, and spend some time practicing or developing their pastry skills? Unbelievable. Everyone should know how to make a pie because it's just an awesome thing to do.

I think Tom casually mentions to Gail every once in a while that she's being too nice, which scares her into a brief fit of snappy remarks. We'll see if this continues.

Top Chef D.C. Episode 4: All Padma wants, is some food for babies, she’s gone tomorrow boy :: Meal Ticket :: Food Blog :: Philadelphia City Paper
Posted 2010-07-10 18:53:49
[...] Winner-of-the-last-ep Arnold, paired up with Lynne, hopes to keep his good performances rolling — maybe if he wins this too, “they might think I’m more than a Louis Vuitton bag!” [...] 
Posted by Drew Lazor @ 10:11 PM  Permalink | Post a comment
0 comments
Comments  (0)


About this blog
Founded in October 2008, Meal Ticket is a City Paper blog about food, drink and assorted other things that make you go mmm. We do recipes, interviews, restaurant news, commentary and much more. We don't do restaurant reviews herethose are handled in print, mostly by our critic (and Meal Ticket contributor) Adam Erace. Got a tip, question, thought or concern? Just want to say hello? Please shoot a note to caroline@citypaper.net.

Follow team Meal Ticket on Twitter:

@mealticket | @carolinerussock | @adamerace

Blog archives:
Past Archives: