Top Chef Season 5, Episode 1: Hey, have you heard? There are places to eat in New York!

PADMA. You. Me. Bottle of Old Grand-Dad. Sack of Totino's Pizza Rolls.  Now does that sound like something you'd be interested in? bravotv.com

email
font size
comments
0
share
options
 

Top Chef Season 5, Episode 1: Hey, have you heard? There are places to eat in New York!

POSTED: Thursday, November 13, 2008, 6:19 PM
Filed Under: Food TV | Top Chef
PADMA. You. Me. Bottle of Old Grand-Dad. Sack
of Totino's Pizza Rolls.  Now does that sound like
something you'd be interested in?
bravotv.com

"As the saying goes, if you can make it here, you can make it anywhere," the transcendently beautiful Padma Lakshmi told the eager contestants on the season premiere of Bravo's Top Chef.

Of course. OF COURSE.

Yes, Season 5 is in New York City. Blablabla so many restaurants that are so good blabla more than half a million industry professionals fighting for six jobs blablabla universal epicenter of all things epicurean bla. anthonybourdain mariobatali ericripert thomaskeller we're better than everyone. We know. WE KNOW.

Sorry. New York always gives me anxiety attacks.

Top Chef is easily the best food show on TV and has always been one of my perennial favorites, and not just because I write articles about turkey burgers and turnovers for a living. People love Project Runway (well, used to at least) due to its almost anti-reality TV reality TV gambit: Yes, there's contrived drama and back-stabbing, but the overriding force driving the show is individual talent and creativity. In other words, you can't lie/cheat/steal/fuck your way through the game on some Real World/Road Rules shit. If you can't make a pencil skirt, you're done.

The same precept can be applied to the Lakshmi/Colicchio variety hour: The viewing populace takes insane pleasure in watching highly qualified industry professionals prepare amuse bouches using preservative-laden snacks they buy out of vending machines, but not because it sucks for them. We just want to see what they come with.

This season's very first Quickfire Challenge, an elimination, had the chefs work on some big apples. (Sigh.) Contestants were instructed to peel 15 with a paring knife, then brunoise 2 cups of said fruit; while top finishers in each round secured their spot on the show, the whittled-down list of stragglers moved further down the gauntlet to the final showdown, which saw them cooking a apple-based dish in 20 minutes. Lauren was tossed back on the ferry she rode in on.

The main challenge involved the remaining chefs shopping in various NY ethnic neighborhoods to create a plate representative of the area. As is the case with any reality TV premiere ep, things are so crowded that it's not only tough to pick favorites, it's also difficult to even register who is who. But as far as I can tell, the top three in this inaugural competition have the chops to get far this year — Hawaiian Gene, who blew Padma away with his unwitting interpretation of Indian cuisine; NY native Leah, who cooks Italian but comes from a "Filipino, Russian-Romanian Jewish background" (what up, sis!); and the challenge winner, Finnish baldheaded Euro shit-talker Stefan.

Young bol Patrick got the boot for screwing up Chinese food. Our dude Erace points out something very intriguing — was he wearing a Tinto shirt?

Favorite moment of the episode: Miami chef Jeff, who to me looks just like the Australian doctor from House, had to cook Latin against Florence-born Fabio. "I live in Miami — I know my Latin," Jeff told the camera with all the force and conviction of a 14-year-old Willie Loman in a middle school production of Death of a Salesman. "He's Italian. It’s a whole 'nother continent."

This is gonna be good.


Pelusi
Posted 2008-11-13 13:31:12
Some initial thoughts: Is Stefan going to be the designated crazy man this season? "A vinaigrette is a vinaigrette!" That was very helpful, because I always thought a vinaigrette was a mulatto, an albino, a mosquito... But I'm not sure he'll measure up to Andrew from Season 4, he of the culinary boner and hot molten fucking lava. I wonder if Gene's "I know nothing about Indian food" was a ruse. If so, he's got the best poker face ever! Finally, YES! Jeff looks exactly like Dr. Robert Chase of Princeton-Plainsboro Teaching Hospital.

chucks
Posted 2008-11-13 13:49:04
A) Pizza Rolls are fucking delicious, and Padma knows it. B) My aunt used to work for Carla (which makes me famous). They share a love for "spirit guides." C) So far Leah is my favorite, mostly because she totally looks like the grown-up version of one of the kids on "John and Kate Plus 8," which I totally don't watch. D) Team Rainbow/Team Eurosnob: Love the love, or hate the immediate cliquiness?

adan
Posted 2008-11-13 13:58:31
The highlight for me was when Alex kept saying Indian food was similar to Latin food. Really, dude? Aside from some curry and coconut crossover, I don't think so. That said, bring on the garam masala tostones.

clint
Posted 2008-11-13 16:29:39
Carla is amazing, though she reminds me of Candyman.

Drew Lazor
Posted 2008-11-13 19:57:58
Pelusi: Of course this is a premature judgment, but I think Stefan is going to be too much of a frontrunner to be considered the "crazy one." My snap judgment is that Carla is going to fill that role this season. She reminds Clint of Tony Todd, for god's sake! Again, very early of course, but I am rooting for Gene this season.

Blue
Posted 2008-11-14 16:37:34
Padma is magnificent.

Meal Ticket :: Blog Archive :: Further proof that Jeff from Top Chef New York and Dr. Robert Chase from House are the same dude :: Philadelphia City Paper :: Philadelphia Arts, Restaurants, Music, Movies, Jobs, Classifieds, Blogs
Posted 2008-11-15 15:39:38
[...] [...]

Meal Ticket :: Blog Archive :: Top Chef Season 5, Episodes 3-4: Foo’s Gold / It’s beginning to look a lot like Jeff-mas :: Philadelphia City Paper :: Philadelphia Arts, Restaurants, Music, Movies, Jobs, Classifieds, Blogs
Posted 2008-12-04 15:34:32
[...] (David Snyder quoted Achatz in his Jan. 2008 piece on “molecular” cooking.) Leah, who I pegged as a frontrunner at the outset, took it with her chilled white asparagus soup with brioche, tuna and tapenade, a spoonable [...]
Posted by Drew Lazor @ 6:19 PM  Permalink | Post a comment
Comments  (0)


About this blog
Founded in October 2008, Meal Ticket is a City Paper blog about food, drink and assorted other things that make you go mmm. We do recipes, interviews, restaurant news, commentary and much more. We don't do restaurant reviews herethose are handled in print, mostly by our critic (and Meal Ticket contributor) Adam Erace. Got a tip, question, thought or concern? Just want to say hello? Please shoot a note to caroline@citypaper.net.

Follow team Meal Ticket on Twitter:

@mealticket | @carolinerussock | @adamerace

Blog archives:
Past Archives: