email
font size
comments
0
options
 
Thursday, December 18, 2008

This week's episode took what felt like an eternity to watch, so I'll try to keep this recap as succinct as possible.

Quickfire Challenge: Martha Stewart came out rocking some skinny jeans surprisingly lithely. She challenged the Top Chef hopefuls to create a "one-pot holiday meal" in 45 minutes. She borrowed a quote from Einstein to convey what she was looking for ("Make it simple, but not too simple"), which marked the first time in history anyone in skinny jeans has quoted Einstein. Our dude Jeff's potato risotto with crispy pork and Brussels sprouts sounded excellent, but Martha thought it sucked; she also criticized Gene's corn starch-thickened Korean pork stew and Fabio's polenta, which means we can safely conclude that Martha Stewart hates ethnic carbs.

One exception: Hosea's paella, which was joined in Martha's top three favorites by Jamie's potato, scallop and kale stew (white person food!) and Ariane's beef and cauliflower purée (even whiter white person food!). Ariane won because she is from Jersey and so is Martha.

After all this, the Harlem Gospel Choir came out and we were treated to a brief glimpse of Padma — who is transcendently beautiful — dancing while getting lifted up by that Holy Spirit. This, my favorite moment of the episode, was at once tremendously pleasing and tremendously uncomfortable. This is going to do wonders for the Find Padma a Mate Campaign.

For the Elimination Challenge, the remaining cheftestants were instructed to craft "12 Days of Christmas"-themed food for a 300-person American Foundation for AIDS Research fundraiser. Forcing Fabio to make a crab dish that somehow conveyed the phrase "nine ladies dancing" was cruel and unusual enough, but the viewing public was fed the biggest load of festive shit by the whole refrigerator issue. The chefs came back to the prep kitchen the morning of the event to discover that one of the fridge doors had been left ajar, rendering Hosea's pork and Radhika's duck spoiled and unservable. Haute tension, dramatic music, Radhika's crying and saying she should pack up and go now, etc. Wait ... what's this? HARK, I spy the True Spirit of Christmas, sitting majestically atop his jingle bell- and wreath-adorned steed, on the horizon! All the other chefs lended a helping hand to get Rad and Hosea back on their feet. Hey, a bunch of extra pork and duck — enough for 300 people! — just happens to be hanging out in the kitchen! Wow, this couldn't have worked out any better. This is what Christmas is all about! Now where is that crippled kid?

You make me sick, Bravo.

And you made me even sicker when you subjected me to all of this pre-fab holiday cheer and then DIDN'T ELIMINATE ANYONE. Hosea got the win, but each of the bottom three chefs — Gene (crappy poisson cru), Jamie (crappy scallop vichyssoise dish, ew) and Melissa (crappily gorgonzola-fied NY strip steak) — were spared. Tom Colicchio is baby Jesus Santa!

Natasha Richardson, aka Liam Neeson's wife, lent her celebrity to the show this week. Her boobs looked really weird to me. Anyone else?


Stev
Posted 2008-12-18 17:16:44
Gorgonzola-fied NY strip steak sounds DELICIOUS. It's a shame it had to be crappily gorgonzola-fied.

clint
Posted 2008-12-18 17:33:13
This episode irked me. It was pretty overbearing with the Christmas-will-save-us-all! stuff. Carla's spirit guide must be Baby Jesus.

DJ
Posted 2008-12-18 18:14:05
Ugh! Talking about beating a dead horse. The spirit guide crack is getting so old.

alice heavey
Posted 2008-12-18 19:24:52
hey drew, maybe the real thing looks weird to you, perhaps you're used to the made to measure variety! as a woman who watches out for these things the only thing i thought was that the dress was very low cut. it might have looked hot, but did you notice she was in a different dress for judges table? maybe she felt uncomfortable?

Drew Lazor
Posted 2008-12-18 21:18:10
Alice: Please believe me when I tell you that I am a vocal and passionate proponent of "the real thing." I just found Natasha's breasts to be visually intriguing. It's difficult for me to articulate, but it almost appeared as though she was wearing a hyper-realistic breast bib, something akin to those airbrushed hot bikini body T-shirts that your aunt buys on the Ocean City boardwalk. Joshua Stein, who's been writing some inspired TC recaps for Gawker, said it quite well: Head on, the woman's breasts — huddled masses yearning to breath free — seemed almost negligible in size. But from the many overhead shots, those same breasts seemed to protrude, jut forward like Nurse Ratchet's "outsized badges of femininity." How did they do that? In conclusion, Natasha Richardson is very beautiful. I just found myself approaching her boobs with a level of academic curiosity.

G Nagle
Posted 2008-12-23 14:59:41
this was my least favorite episode of this show over all the seasons.

Meal Ticket :: Blog Archive :: I’m really looking forward to this week’s Top Chef. :: Philadelphia City Paper :: Philadelphia Arts, Restaurants, Music, Movies, Jobs, Classifieds, Blogs
Posted 2008-12-29 13:01:06
[...] G Nagle: this was my least favorite episode of this show over all the seasons. [...]
Posted by Drew Lazor @ 10:00 PM  Permalink | File Under: Food TV | | Top Chef | Post a comment
Comments   


0 comments
About Meal Ticket
Founded in October 2008, Meal Ticket is a City Paper blog about food, drink and assorted other things that make you go mmm. We do recipes, interviews, restaurant news, commentary and much more. We don't do restaurant reviews herethose are handled in print, mostly by our critic (and Meal Ticket contributor) Adam Erace. Got a tip, question, thought or concern? Just want to say hello? Please shoot a note to drew.lazor@citypaper.net.

Follow Meal Ticket, Adam and Drew on Twitter: @mealticket | @adamerace | @drewlazor